
LeetCode 36: Valid Sudoku Explained – Java Solutions, Intuition & Formula Dry Run
IntroductionSudoku is a universally beloved puzzle, but validating a Sudoku boardalgorithmically is a classic technical interview question. In this post, we aregoing to dive deep into LeetCode 36: Valid Sudoku.We won't just look at the code; we will explore the intuition behind the problemso you don't have to memorize anything. We’ll cover an ingenious in-placevalidation approach, break down the complex math formula used to check3 \times 3 sub-boxes, and look at an alternative optimal solution usingHashSets.Let's dive in!Understanding the ProblemThe problem asks us to determine if a partially filled 9 \times 9 Sudoku boardis valid. To be valid, the filled cells must follow three straightforward rules:1. Each row must contain the digits 1-9 without repetition.2. Each column must contain the digits 1-9 without repetition.3. Each of the nine 3 \times 3 sub-boxes must contain the digits 1-9 withoutrepetition.Important Note: A valid board doesn't mean the board is fully solvable! We onlycare about checking the numbers that are currently on the board.Intuition: How to Think About the ProblemBefore writing code, how do we, as humans, check if a Sudoku board is valid? Ifyou place a 5 in a cell, you quickly scan horizontally (its row), vertically(its column), and within its small 3 \times 3 square. If you see another 5, theboard is invalid.To translate this to code, we have two choices:1. The Simulation Approach: Go cell by cell. Pick up the number, hide it, andcheck its row, column, and 3 \times 3 box to see if that number existsanywhere else. (This is the approach we will look at first).2. The Memory Approach: Go cell by cell, but keep a "notebook" (like a HashTable) of everything we have seen so far. If we see a number we've alreadywritten down for a specific row, column, or box, it's invalid.Approach 1: The In-Place Validation (Space-Optimized)Here is a brilliant solution that validates the board without using any extradata structures.The Logic: Iterate through every cell on the board. When we find a number, wetemporarily replace it with a . (empty space). Then, we iterate 9 times to checkits entire row, column, and sub-box. If the number is found, we return false.Otherwise, we put the number back and move to the next cell.The Java Codeclass Solution {public boolean isvalid(char[][] board, int i, int j, char k) {for(int m = 0; m < 9; m++) {// Check rowif(board[i][m] == k) return false;// Check columnif(board[m][j] == k) return false;// Check 3x3 sub-boxif(board[3 * (i / 3) + m / 3][3 * (j / 3) + m % 3] == k) return false;}return true;}public boolean isValidSudoku(char[][] board) {for(int i = 0; i < board.length; i++) {for(int j = 0; j < board[0].length; j++) {if(board[i][j] != '.') {char temp = board[i][j];board[i][j] = '.'; // Temporarily remove the numberif(!isvalid(board, i, j, temp)) {return false;}board[i][j] = temp; // Put the number back}}}return true;}}The Math Breakdown: Demystifying the 3 \times 3 Grid FormulaThe hardest part of this code to understand is this exact line: board[3*(i/3) +m/3][3*(j/3) + m%3]How does a single loop variable m (from 0 to 8) traverse a 3 \times 3 grid?Let’s do a dry run.Step 1: Finding the Starting Point of the BoxThe grid is 9 \times 9, broken into nine 3 \times 3 boxes. If we are at a randomcell, say row i = 4, col j = 5, which box are we in? Because integer division inJava drops the decimal:i / 3 = 4 / 3 = 1j / 3 = 5 / 3 = 1Now multiply by 3 to get the actual starting coordinates (top-left corner) ofthat specific sub-box:3 * 1 = 3 (Row offset)3 * 1 = 3 (Col offset) So, the 3 \times 3 box starts at row 3, col 3.Step 2: Traversing the Box (Dry Run)Now, as m goes from 0 to 8, we use m / 3 for rows and m % 3 for columns:m = 0: row offset 0/3 = 0, col offset 0%3 = 0 \rightarrow Checks (3+0, 3+0) = (3, 3)m = 1: row offset 1/3 = 0, col offset 1%3 = 1 \rightarrow Checks (3+0, 3+1) = (3, 4)m = 2: row offset 2/3 = 0, col offset 2%3 = 2 \rightarrow Checks (3+0, 3+2) = (3, 5)m = 3: row offset 3/3 = 1, col offset 3%3 = 0 \rightarrow Checks (3+1, 3+0) = (4, 3)m = 4: row offset 4/3 = 1, col offset 4%3 = 1 \rightarrow Checks (3+1, 3+1) = (4, 4)...and so on up to m = 8.This brilliant math formula maps a 1D loop (0 to 8) directly onto a 2D3 \times 3 grid perfectly! No nested loops needed inside the isvalid function.Approach 2: The HashSet Solution (Single Pass)While the first approach is highly space-efficient, it does a bit of redundantchecking. An alternative approach that interviewers love is using a HashSet.Instead of checking rows and columns every time we see a number, we generate aunique "string signature" for every number and attempt to add it to a HashSet.If we see a 5 at row 0 and col 1, we create three strings:1. "5 in row 0"2. "5 in col 1"3. "5 in block 0-0"The HashSet.add() method returns false if the item already exists in the set. Ifit returns false, we instantly know the board is invalid!HashSet Java Code:class Solution {public boolean isValidSudoku(char[][] board) {HashSet<String> seen = new HashSet<>();for (int i = 0; i < 9; i++) {for (int j = 0; j < 9; j++) {char number = board[i][j];if (number != '.') {// HashSet.add() returns false if the element already existsif (!seen.add(number + " in row " + i) ||!seen.add(number + " in col " + j) ||!seen.add(number + " in block " + i/3 + "-" + j/3)) {return false;}}}}return true;}}Notice how we use i/3 + "-" + j/3 to identify the blocks. Top-left is block 0-0,bottom-right is block 2-2.Time and Space Complexity BreakdownInterviewers will always ask for your complexity analysis. Because a Sudokuboard is strictly fixed at 9 \times 9, the strict Big-O is actually constant.However, let's look at it conceptually as if the board were N \times N.Approach 1: In-Place Validation (Your Solution)Time Complexity: O(1) (Strictly speaking). We traverse 81 cells, and foreach cell, we do at most 9 iterations. 81 \times 9 = 729 operations. Since729 is a constant, it's O(1). (If the board was N \times N, time complexitywould be O(N^3) because for N^2 cells, we iterate N times).Space Complexity: O(1). We only use primitive variables (i, j, k, m, temp).No extra memory is allocated.Approach 2: HashSet ApproachTime Complexity: O(1). We traverse the 81 cells exactly once. Generatingstrings and adding to a HashSet takes O(1) time. (If the board wasN \times N, time complexity would be O(N^2)).Space Complexity: O(1). The HashSet will store a maximum of81 \times 3 = 243 strings. Since this upper limit is fixed, space isconstant.ConclusionThe Valid Sudoku problem is a fantastic exercise in matrix traversal andcoordinate math.When solving this in an interview:1. Use the first approach if you want to impress the interviewer with O(1)space complexity and your deep understanding of math formulas (the /3 and %3trick).2. Use the second approach (HashSet) if you want to show off your knowledge ofdata structures and write highly readable, clean, and clever code.I hope this breakdown gives you the intuition needed so you never have tomemorize the code for LeetCode 36!Happy Coding! Keep Learning🤟





